Disciplinary Action Lawyers Fourtree Lawyers Newcastle & Central Coast NSW 2250

What is disciplinary action?

Action by an employer against an employee which does not (at least immediately) result in termination of employment falls into two general categories:

  • performance-related conduct, and inappropriate conduct or misconduct.
  • Due to poor performance, inappropriate conduct or misconduct in the workplace, disciplinary procedures require diplomacy, discretion, and due process.

It is imperative businesses have their performance plans and disciplinary procedures in place. Hence, there is no question about what is expected of staff and what will happen if they don’t meet required standards, behave inappropriately or engage in serious misconduct.

EMPLOYEES – Click for more information

Employees need to be aware of their rights in the workplace to ensure they are not being bullied, discriminated against or unfairly treated.

The team at Fourtree Lawyers knows that being called into a disciplinary meeting for underperforming, inappropriate conduct or serious misconduct can be a daunting process. We understand your job is important to you and we can help you minimise the risk of being dismissed, suspended or demoted. By keeping a cool head, understanding your rights and seeking good legal advice, you can minimise these risks.

Tips for dealing with being called into a disciplinary meeting

  1. Get advice from a lawyer or a union official
  2. Before the meeting, ask for copies of any allegations against you in writing
  3. Find a support person or union representative to attend the meeting
  4. Document everything that is said in the meeting
  5. Ask that the meeting is not recorded via video or audio.
  6. Do not buckle to the pressure to resign or be demoted
  7. Make sure you understand the questions and don’t answer anything you are unsure of
  8. Do not admit to anything if accused of serious misconduct, as information provided may be passed on to the police.

How can I minimise the risk of being seen to be underperforming?

Minimise the risk of being seen to be underperforming by communicating openly with your managers, asking for feedback and taking notes at performance appraisals.
You should:

  • Have a detailed job description and understand performance targets
  • Ask for feedback
  • Ask for regular appraisals and keep documentation pertaining to this.

Can I be dismissed on the spot for underperforming?

An employer should follow certain procedures regarding disciplinary matters. They must make you aware of the problem, provide counselling and extra training and give you time to improve. If the situation doesn’t improve and you are still underperforming, they have grounds to dismiss or demote you.

Can I be sacked on the spot for serious misconduct?

For serious misconduct allegations such as fraud, assault or theft, your employee should thoroughly investigate the claims being made against you. You should be allowed to respond to allegations and evidence procured. You could be suspended from work, usually with pay, while these proceedings take place.

If you are called to a meeting to answer serious misconduct allegations, seek advice from the team at Fourtree Lawyers.

What happens if I am demoted, suspended or dismissed for underperforming, inappropriate conduct or serious misconduct?

It is advisable to seek legal advice. The team at Fourtree Lawyers will explore every legal avenue available to you to determine if you can challenge any of the above outcomes or are entitled to make a claim for damages or losses incurred.

EMPLOYERS – Click for more information

Managing an employee who is unable or unwilling to do their job, whether due to personal factors, being out of their depth or simply having a bad attitude towards work, or who has engaged in serious misconduct, is a common problem in the workplace.

And it is one of the most challenging and risky aspects of running a business.

If it is not managed properly, a difficult employee could claim damages against your business.

Fourtree Lawyers can help you manage your employees by:

  • Drafting performance plans and policies;
  • Drafting disciplinary procedures; and
  • Providing advice in dealing with poor performance and misconduct
  • Providing advice on disciplinary measures, demotion and terminations

Do I need to give an employee a warning in writing before terminating their employment?

It is considered best practice to let your employees know they are underperforming and give them the opportunity to improve before dismissing them. Warnings need to be clear, provide clear expectations and be fair and reasonable.

By failing to give a warning and a chance to improve, your employee could make an unfair dismissal claim to the Fair Work Commission.

The experienced staff at Fourtree Lawyers provides expert advice on warnings and terminating staff, reducing the risk of a claim being made against your business.

Can I dismiss an employee for breaking company rules?

Yes, but only if you have made the employee aware of the rules. Clearly drafted and concise company policies should be made available to all staff.

Why do I need a performance plan?

A performance plan should be made clear to an employee at the start of a new role. It’s an opportunity to ascertain:

  • what they are going to do
  • how they are going to do it
  • knowledge and skills needed for the job
  • performance reviews

This provides a template for assessing an employees’ performance.

Why do I need a performance policy?

A performance policy is important so everyone is on the same page. It will outline what will happen if an employee is underperforming. It should include the number of written and verbal warnings that will be issued to a worker before being dismissed.

Why do I need disciplinary procedures?

It is important to have clear and concise disciplinary procedures in place to reduce the risk of legal proceedings, which could include damages for unfair dismissal or discrimination in the workplace.

What are disciplinary procedures?

All staff should be familiar with disciplinary procedures and understand the steps involved, including:

  • Initiating a meeting to warn an employee of concerns and giving them an opportunity to improve
  • Counselling so that employees understand what is required and are given guidance to improve
  • Keeping records of discussions at counselling sessions
  • Providing further training to get them up to speed
  • Keeping records of measures taken to deal with problems such as counselling, further training and poor performance
  • Information about how many warnings will be issued before an underperformer is dismissed
  • Providing employees with the right to a union representative, support person or witness
  • Making employees aware that instant dismissal will be applied for serious and wilful misconduct

What happens if performance doesn’t improve after a disciplinary meeting?

If your employee’s performance doesn’t improve, you can:

  • Initiate another meeting
  • Change the employee’s duties
  • Provide additional training
  • Terminate employment

For terminations, businesses need to make sure their workers are not being unfairly dismissed and are given termination notice and their final pay.
Fourtree Lawyers provides expert advice in managing disciplinary issues and terminations.

How can I prevent underperformance?

Clear communication is key to managing performance and includes listing expectations in your job description, addressing issues as soon as they arise, holding regular performance reviews and encouraging employees to communicate concerns with their managers.

We are here to help

Our solicitors specialise in Employment Law and represent clients throughout the Hunter, Newcastle, Sydney and across the Central Coast. We have the experience to guide you through often complex workplace issues from beginning to end to ensure you get you the best possible outcome.

If you have a workplace issue or dispute, call one of our Employment law specialists on 1300 529 444 or submit a contact form to arrange a case assessment with one of our solicitors today.

More Reading -

What is unfair dismissal?



  • Kevin and Jane are without a doubt 100% there to support you through Your whole ordeal reassuring you all the way My experience from finding Fourtree Lawyers on Google in a fairly unsure position, reading the reviews to the successful outcomes was the only referral I had, believe me when I say you will be happy with their experience in all fields of law which is insurmountable and they will obtain the best favourable outcome in any circumstance. Fourtree Lawyers are there for you to bring things back into perspective...

    RS - Port Macquarie

  • “Kevin and Jane were my “knights in shining armour.” I can’t thank these two people enough. They gave their everything and most important believed me when I told them my story. I am forever grateful for their professional attitude and for giving 100% to free me from my nightmare. I was able to plead guilty but also most importantly was not forced to lie and compromise my integrity and own personal values and standards. I was very happy with the outcome and the way I was treated. They communicated constantly...

    VR - Charmhaven

  • Had the most amazing experience with Fourtree Lawyers kevin vierboom who represented my partner was helpful and understanding and we got a great result better then expected ? jane hogan, I was so blessed to have her by my side. They are an amazing team and i would recommend them to everyone also great value for money. Especially considering i only called the morning of the court case and they were all over it at my bek and call thankyou so much guys im so appreciative for all your help today

    AB - Budgewoi

  • I was lucky enough to have Kevin take my case and am truly grateful for the services he and his team provided. From the outset, I was made to feel comfortable and knew from the first time meeting with them that they would go above and beyond to get the best possible outcome and that is exactly what they did. Fourtree Lawyers provides exceptional service with outstanding results and I would recommend Kevin to anyone and everyone who is in need of these services.

    OC - Avoca Beach

Client Reviews

Fourtree Lawyers were brilliant! Kevin and his team were great! They gave me time to question and fully understand what was happening and suggested the best way forward. While I would hate anyone to have to fight the government to keep their job Kevin had the patience and expertise to explain the difficulties presented and eventually win my case. I have no hesitation in recommending Fourtree Lawyers and know they will do their best to help, whatever circumstance you may find yourself.